Fri
27
Mar
2009
ABNA Results
Well, after six weeks, I finally got word that I'd made into the top 2,000 entries (10,000 were possible, but I don't know if Amazon received that many) based upon my "pitch" (which I took to mean my query sans biographical info). However, I didn't advance to the quarterfinals, which were decided by a different set of judges, Amazon Vine Reviewers, who read the first 5,000 words of my novel.
I've been promised the reviews from the Vine Reviewers, but so far, zilch. I don't know why those reviews wouldn't have come simultaneously with the rejection, if they existed to provide a basis for that rejection.
In reading the Amazon entrants' discussion threads, I've learned that the Vine Reviews aren't necessarily the deciding factor for advancing (scuttlebut has it that some reviewers are rather surprised that excerpts they rated poorly advanced). So it's hard to know how to judge the feedback I'll get.
1 Comment
-
#1
The Vine Reviews came in about three weeks after I got dropped. They weren't bad, though mixed. Apparently neither reviewer had any idea that my novel had a mermaid in it. One liked the surprise, but the other didn't. Both described the opening as treating the material well ("not cheesy" was the first reviewer's comment) while the second compared the opening to The Sex Lives of the Cannibals minus the humor.


